A narrow sandy trail curves between dormant golden grasses and junipers in Santa Fe's softly lit high-desert foothills.

The Shortcut Into La Tierra Trails Now Crosses Land in Federal Court

On most mornings, cars are parked along the shoulder of Camino La Tierra just north of N.M. 599. From there, footpaths and tire tracks run across open foothill ground toward the La Tierra trail system. That system has 25 miles of paths for hikers, bikers and horseback riders, plus the nearby Buckman track for all-terrain vehicles. The Santa Fe New Mexican describes that ground as private and undeveloped.

The trails are owned by the City of Santa Fe, and nobody is litigating them. The approach from Camino La Tierra is a different matter. It sits on the site of the Camino Verde subdivision, a 158-lot plan that Santa Fe County commissioners denied on June 30. Since October 15, that denial has been before a federal court.

Two owners on one walk

From the road shoulder to the far reaches of La Tierra, a walk crosses two kinds of ownership. The New Mexican reports that the trail system sits on City property. The Santa Fe Conservation Trust has helped maintain it for more than a decade under agreements with the City. The Trust's own page dates those contracts and voluntary agreements to 2014. The same page credits the Trust, the Santa Fe Fat Tire Society and the City with building the Hustle and Flow trail that year.

The land between the road and the City property is a separate piece of the map. The County's case file describes it as 304.54 acres on two vacant parcels at 25 Blue Canyon Trail and 36 Camino La Tierra, north of Highway 599. The parcels are zoned Residential Estate. The New Mexican describes the paths across those acres as trails that wind through private, undeveloped property on the way to La Tierra.

The plan would have made the paths official

The Camino Verde application came from Chicago-based Samara Real Property, County Case 26-5050. It asked for 158 lots built in four phases, and some lots would have been smaller than an acre. According to the New Mexican's report on the vote, the developer's representatives said the project would protect access to the La Tierra system and keep 5 miles of trails on the parcels. A county report said half the property would remain natural open space, which qualified the project for a density bonus under the county's Sustainable Development Land Use Code.

According to a county summary of the project, that open space would have held a network of public trails. The appeal coverage adds that 18 of the homes would have been designated affordable.

The plan also covered infrastructure. Homes would have been on a private, on-site community wastewater system and connected to the county's public water system, with estimated demand of about 12.8 million gallons a year. The County's meeting summary lists those same subjects as the grounds for denial: traffic and safety, density, and the proposed wastewater plan. At that meeting, according to the New Mexican, Commissioner Lisa Cacari Stone said the developer "could come back with a new conceptual plan, but I want to see a more modest development that fits with the infrastructure that exists there."

From a county vote to a federal docket

The case did not stop with the commission's vote.

Date, 2026 Step Where it happened
June 9 Public comment heard; case tabled 4–0 and continued to June 30 County Commission
June 30 Conceptual plan denied 3–2 County Commission
August 11 Final order memorializing the denial adopted 3–2 County Commission
September 10 Developer files an appeal First Judicial District Court, Santa Fe
October 15 Case removed to federal court U.S. District Court for New Mexico
October 20–21 County and two commissioners file motions to dismiss; the commissioners also seek a stay U.S. District Court
October 23 Case reassigned to District Judge Matthew L. Garcia U.S. District Court
November 2 Plaintiffs file notices about extensions to respond U.S. District Court

According to the New Mexican, the September appeal alleges that the county gave Camino Verde a "hearing in name only" and denied the developer a fair and impartial hearing. A County spokesperson told the paper the County does not comment on pending litigation.

The move to federal court started with the defendants. The federal docket on Justia shows the notice of removal was filed on October 15 by two commissioners named in the suit. It transferred state case D-101-CV-2026-02574 to federal case 1:26-cv-03446, filed as a civil rights matter. The plaintiffs are Samara Real Property and Easy Park Acquisitions, both Delaware limited liability companies.

The docket's most recent update is from November 6. At that point the motions to dismiss had no ruling and the developer's responses were still under extension. The case started as a dispute over a 158-lot subdivision. In federal court, the first questions are whether the claims survive at all.

The ground at 25 Blue Canyon Trail and 36 Camino La Tierra is still private, and the commission denied its only conceptual plan.

The entrances the City and the Trust maintain

The trail system itself has entrances that don't depend on how the case turns out. The Santa Fe Conservation Trust lists two ways in from town: Camino de los Montoyas and the Dog Park Connector.

  • Frijoles Trailhead, on Camino de los Montoyas. This is where the Trust held its November 4 La Tierra work day. It is also home to the Frijoles Skills Park. The Santa Fe Fat Tire Society reports six new steel-framed, wood-decked ramps there. Rocket Ramps designed and built them, and the club paid for them with a $90,000 grant from the New Mexico Outdoor Recreation Division's Trails+ program. The club scheduled the ribbon cutting for June 13.
  • The Dog Park Connector. The Trust and its GUSTO partners built this route with the City. It runs through City open space and reaches La Tierra by way of the Montoyas Trail and an underpass beneath the Relief Route. The Trust's plan for the route puts it at about 0.56 mile between two existing open-space gates.
  • Buckman Track, in the southwest corner. Motorized vehicles are allowed here and nowhere else in the system.

The same rules apply at every entrance. Dogs must be leashed, horses are allowed in parts of the system, and hikers, runners and cyclists can use the whole of it. The Trust also has an interpretive La Tierra Chili Line Trail project underway on the old railbed near Buckman Track. Its 2020 plan called for a quarter-mile trail along the historic Denver & Rio Grande grade, with gates, fencing and signs.

Who looks after the City side

The Trust keeps the City-owned miles in shape partly with volunteers. Its Wednesday trail work days run from 9 a.m. to noon, and each one depends on the weather. Venues are posted on the Trust's event calendar and change week to week. Some sessions are at La Tierra and some are elsewhere. The Fat Tire Society has a stated policy of riding, building and maintaining only sanctioned trails, in cooperation with land managers. The club notes that one of its La Tierra reroute projects needed the City's permission before work could start.

Under Judge Garcia, the case will next decide whether the developer's claims go forward. Until then, a morning at La Tierra can begin at Frijoles Trailhead on Camino de los Montoyas, on ground the City owns.

Our team follows county land-use filings like Case 26-5050, along with the parcels, plats and easements behind Santa Fe's favorite trails, as closely as we follow the market. If you want to understand what sits beside a property you own or are considering, Numi Hirsch welcomes you to request a private consultation.

Work With Us

Ready to make Santa Fe your home? Reach out to us for expert guidance and a personalized real estate experience.

Follow Us on Instagram